Skip to content
Student loans from £100 to £3,000
Free to use365 days

Home Money Talk Bedroom tax loophole could benefit thousands

Bedroom tax loophole could benefit thousands

Written in January 2014. Some figures and rules may have changed since, so check the latest before you act on anything here.

Students sitting together working on laptops

It appears there has been a chaotic error in the “bedroom tax” (the tax that applies to social housing tenants). Thousands of people are now entitled to get their money back as they were wrongly charged.

How the bedroom tax loophole arose

The loophole arose because of a mistake in the bedroom tax legislation, which means it does not actually apply to anyone who has lived in the same building for more than seventeen years. Housing experts have said that up to 40,000 people could be affected by this and entitled to their money back. That is around one in twenty-five benefit claimants who have been wrongly taxed. The Department for Work and Pensions remains stubbornly defiant and believes that “few people will be affected”.

Each of these people could be entitled to refunds of around £640. This will amount to millions for the government: millions of pounds that it has wrongly taken from people.

Chris Bryant, the shadow welfare reform minister, has said that the government should think about scrapping the tax altogether, rather than trying to adjust the loopholes. He has called this “the latest example of chaos and confusion under Iain Smith”.

Should the bedroom tax be scrapped?

The bedroom tax currently affects 660,000 benefit claimants who live in social housing. The policy is imposed on people who have “more bedrooms than they need”, according to the government, and so have to pay a weekly tax of between 14 and 22 pounds.

Forget about the people who have been wrongly taxed (although don’t, because it’s important): what about anyone paying this tax at all? It is forcing people into the private sector, and into poverty. The government should get rid of the bedroom tax altogether, which would also save it the “administrative hassle” of having to track down every single person it has been ripping off for the past 18 years.