Skip to content
Student loans from £100 to £3,000
Free to use365 days

Home Money Talk Safety concerns as young drivers purchase 'unsafe' second hand vehicles because of the high cost of buying new

Safety concerns as young drivers purchase 'unsafe' second hand vehicles because of the high cost of buying new

Written in November 2017. Some figures and rules may have changed since, so check the latest before you act on anything here.

Old car broken down at the roadside with smoke from the engine

It’s an exciting time for teenagers and parents alike when a child reaches 17 and can start driving lessons and make the great leap into independence.

It’s an even greater feeling when that child passes their test and they, along with their parents, can rush off and choose a car to drive around in.

Why parents choose cheap, older cars

The natural thing for parents to do is consider getting a cheap run-around for their newly qualified driver, and this will often mean a small car that is a good few years old and has a fair bit of mileage on it, but seems reliable enough once its history has been checked. And to be fair, why shouldn’t parents opt for a cheap run-around? No doubt they will already, alongside their child, be paying enough in car insurance without wanting to blow a fortune on a new car as well. After all, under-25s are theoretically more likely to have a crash than any other demographic, and a considerable number of newly qualified drivers make a claim within their first year on the road – so it is easy to see why people wouldn’t want to spend a fortune on a first car.

According to research from an insurance group, though, parents should think again before buying a cheap car for their child, as they could be buying a car that is deemed unsafe compared with newer models that achieve 5-star safety ratings. Co-op Insurance has stated that parents are putting driver safety in jeopardy by buying older cars that are cheap to run.

The insurer said that people’s priorities included the make and model of the car (something cool to be seen in), its colour and how cheap it was to insure – not how safe the vehicle was.

The high cost of insurance for young drivers

We can completely understand insurance being a priority for many people, but on the flip side of the coin, we appreciate that safety should be of paramount importance too.

From a parent’s and young driver’s point of view, the costs of getting a car and insuring it are astronomical, so if there is any saving to be made, people are surely going to take it. Everyone knows that insurance for young people is a joke and all too often runs into the thousands. This would wipe many people out financially, and that is before you have even bought a vehicle! After sorting out insurance, most people will only have a few hundred pounds to spare, and they are going to get whatever vehicle they can afford. This is never going to be something new on the market with all-singing, all-dancing safety features.

In our opinion, car insurance companies need better regulation; they are running riot and the cost of insurance is getting out of control. Young drivers are literally being priced off the roads. Better regulation and cheaper premiums could benefit all parties. If insurance premiums weren’t so expensive, people would be able to afford better cars with higher safety ratings. This would make our roads safer and would also help the car industry, with sales of new cars going up.

Putting safety first

We must finish this piece by echoing what the research highlights, though. Even though we are a finance site and our main aim is to talk about and offer tips on money, saving and budgeting, we appreciate that safety should always come first.

In our opinion, cars that don’t have electronic braking systems and 5-star safety ratings are not fit to be running on the same roads as vehicles that do boast these systems.

Always put safety first. We appreciate it will be hard when finances are stretched, but try to get the balance as right as possible.